Demo by Wysor for Louisiana lobbyists. "Sample Client (roofing contractor)" is a made-up client to show how a client alert looks.
November 12, 2026 · Official meeting page
The Joint Insurance Committee heard from a Florida insurance attorney on how Florida's 2022 and 2023 reforms (ending assignment of benefits for new policies and repealing one-way attorney fees) were followed by lower litigation, new carriers and falling rates. Members questioned him on fairness, loser-pays fees, statutes of limitations, adjuster quality and bad faith. Insurance Commissioner Tim Temple reported 25 newly licensed homeowner carriers, rate reductions and growth in the Fortified Roof Program. No bills were voted on, and the committee adjourned.
Sample Client (roofing contractor) came up at:
Kirk Talbot
All right, if everybody takes their seats, we will get ready. Secretary Russell will call the roll for the Senate. Senator Talbot, here.
Russell (Senate Secretary)
Present. Senator Bass, present. Senator Barrow, Senator Carter, Senator Edmonds, Senator Foyle, Senator Myers, Senator Seabrook, Senator Wheat, here. Present.
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
All right, now we'll call the House.
Russell (Committee secretary)
Representative Firment? Representative Bagley? Present. Representative Bamburg? Present. Representative Freeman? Representative Gallais? Present. Representative Glorioso? Present. Representative Green? Representative Hebert? Present. Representative Henry? Present. Um, Representative Illg? Present. Representative Jordan. Representative Millerine. Present. Representative Mena. Representative Murray. Representative Phelps. Representative Wilder. Present.
Kirk Talbot
All right. So we have a small agenda today. Fred Karlinski is here. Why don't you come up and tell us who you are, tell us what you do. When I heard you were in town, I knew we had some of our members in town because we have some other meetings last night and today. We just kind of wanted to get your take. I know you have a very plugged into what's going on in Florida. And I keep reading headline after headline about Florida's rates going down, companies going there, rate reductions, premium reductions, insurance companies like USAA giving $1 billion back. So I thought, hey, you know, we want to know what's, what's going on. So I appreciate you taking time to come see us and Just, you know, give us your full name, what you do, and then just kind of tell us what's going on in Florida.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
So, thanks very much, Chairman, and happy to do that. And members, it's a distinct honor to be here today. I appreciate you taking the time to hear from me. So, my name is Fred Karlinski. I live in Florida. I'm with the law firm of Greenberg Traurig, which is an international law firm. I'm the global chair of the insurance practice. At Greenberg, we've got 3,200 lawyers in 51 offices in 16 countries. I am a Miami native. I went to the University of Miami. By the way, Saturday night, that was a catch. There's no question about that. A lot of people's teams lost Saturday. And we have something in common. We, none of us like the Gators, right? But, and then I went to Florida State University College of Law, where I've been an adjunct professor of law for the last 18 years teaching insurance. law and risk management. After leaving law school, I worked at— I was the general counsel and the assistant executive director for something called Florida Residential Property and Casualty Joint Underwriting Association, which was the precursor to Our Citizens. And while there, it was immediately after Hurricane Andrew, which was in August of 1992. '92. I graduated law school in December of '92, started there in '95. We did the first purchase of reinsurance for a residual market, the first what is now cat bonds, the first letter of credit. And these were billions of dollars. That entity had over a million policies in it. We did the first depopulation program and brought that down to about 60,000 policies, which we were extremely proud of doing. I've got some strong ties here in the state of Louisiana. I helped you all start Louisiana Citizens, which, for those that may need a primer on Citizens for a second, I will just tell you that the thing we did there that was transformational is prior to the creation of that in Florida and then the creation of that in Louisiana, if you had a year where you had profit in that entity, meaning there wasn't a storm, the premiums exceeded the losses, and so you were able to effectively have a buffer, you actually had to pay federal income tax on that. And then if there were losses in years going forward, you would get that money back through a refund. We changed that. We worked with the IRS in Florida and then in Louisiana with a private letter ruling where that money now, whether there's a loss or otherwise, stays in the entity. And so it's much more tax efficient. So I can't speak to some of the nuances of Citizens and the operational issues, but I can tell you— Yeah. From the standpoint of capital efficiency, that's really worked. Secondly, I've helped start and bring a number of carriers into the state of Louisiana, and I'm very proud of that because it's important to bring capital to states. That's how you get coverage in a state for insurance. And so, we did the most recent startup in Louisiana, a newer company that started just a few months ago. Last but not least, for the last 27 years, I've been married to a woman I'm coming from New Iberia, Louisiana. So the first time I ever had rabbit, which they lied to me and told me was chicken, was in Lafayette. But that's probably my closest connection. Last but not least, I just want to take a point of personal privilege. I work very closely with your Insurance Commissioner, Tim Temple, and the people at the Louisiana Insurance Department. We deal with all 50 states. I can tell you there's no finer group than the group you have here, and you should be really proud of the work they do. Commissioner Temple. I guess he'll now be a veteran because we're going to have so many changes at the NAIC, but his knowledge of insurance and his capabilities makes him just— makes him second to none in terms of insurance commissioners. So I really appreciate the work that they do, and you should be congratulated for such a great department. What I want to do this morning is tell you a story about my home state of Florida. It's not a very flattering story, but for the better part of 15 years, Florida has had the most dysfunctional property insurance market in the country. Let me also real quick, before I go on to that, give you a disclaimer. Nothing I'm going to talk about is legal advice. And these are my opinions, not the opinions of anyone that's a client. Premiums in Florida were the highest in the nation. Insurers were going insolvent. National carriers were walking away. And the state insurer of last resort, Citizens, kept swelling because the private market Kept shrinking. Here's the lesson I really want you guys to take home today, and I'll say it once at the beginning, and I think I'll prove it over the next 40 minutes. For most of those years, Florida treated symptoms. We saw a spike in mold claims, so we limited mold coverage. We saw a spike in sinkhole claims, so we rewrote the sinkhole statute. Each time, the particular claim that we targeted went down, and each time we congratulated ourselves and patted ourselves on the back, and the abuse simply moved to the next line of coverage. The systems— the symptoms kept changing. The disease never did. The disease was a business model that still holds true today in Florida and in other states. Contractors and adjusters who took an assignment of a homeowner's insurance benefits inflated the claim and then used Florida's one-way attorney fee statute to make it cheaper for the insurer to pay them than to fight. Bottom line is When you're looking at the reforms that you're going to do here, and I know in 2023 you did away with assignment of benefits, which I applaud you for greatly, uh, the fact that we had this one-way attorney fee in Florida statute, which was unique, really made our lives a little bit easier once we got that done. It was a silver bullet in the state of Florida. But mold, water, sinkholes, those were just the hosts. The organism, organism was the same. Florida did not get well in insurance until the end of 2022 and the beginning of 2023, when the legislature finally stopped changing symptoms and treating the disease. It ended the assignment of benefits model for new policies, and it repealed the one-way attorney fee statute, which was critical. The market responded almost immediately. And I'll show you that too. So here's the arc that we were dealing with: mold, which mold was gold, to water, to sinkholes, to the reckoning with assignment of benefits and fee shifting, and then the recovery. Let me walk you through that a little bit. So starting in the late 2000s and early 2010s, the industry had a saying: mold was gold. Here's how it worked. A homeowner had a plumbing leak, a small plumbing leak, a supply line behind a wall, a slow drip under a sink. Ordinary covered water damage. A water mitigation contractor shows up, often before the insurer has ever been notified. The homeowner signs a one-page form, the assignment of benefit, to the contractor. The contractor now has complete control of that claim. He bills the insurer directly, and the invoice is not for just drying out a wall. It's for mold testing, it's for containment chambers, it's for air scrubbers, it's for demolition, it's for remediation, and many other things, frequently at rates that are 30-plus percent higher or more than comparable market work. I don't know about you, but it was a little surprising to me to find that mold had never existed until the 2000s in the state of Florida. I obviously say that in jest. That pre-reform fact pattern is not a caricature. It's the exact scenario that Florida's appellate courts were describing. In one representative case, a homeowner with water damage hired a company for emergency water removal and construction services and executed an assignment of benefits authorizing the contractor to bill the insurer directly. And the courts documented the broader pattern. A Florida appellate court reviewing the record noted evidence of inflated or fraud— fraudulent, and that's a quote, post-loss remediation claims exceeding comparable services by 30%, policyholders signing away rights they did not understand, and a, quote, cottage industry, unquote, of vendors, contractors, and attorneys using assignments and the threat of litigation to extract higher payments from insurers. The insurers' first response from this was not to go to the legislatures to get to change the coverage forms. In Florida, as in Louisiana, as in every other state in the United States, an insurer on an admitted basis cannot simply use any policy language that it wants. Every policy form, every endorsement needs to be filed and approved by the state regulator before it can be used. The regulator can disapprove a form only on specified grounds. For example, if it's inconsistent with the insurance code, or for residential property, it's unfair or inequitable, or if it contains exceptions and conditions that deceptively affect the risk. Working within that approval framework, insurers filed and the regulator approved endorsements that did 2 things: they excluded mold almost entirely in the state of Florida, And they capped non-weather water damage. You can see the results in the case law that followed in Florida. Florida courts enforced total mold exclusions. One appellate decision upheld a fungus, including mold exclusion endorsement that removed fungus from the policy's coverage entirely. Another enforced a blanket mold exclusion against a remediation company that took an assignment Even where the mold followed a hurricane-created opening. So insurers introduced limited water damage endorsements as well, and they put a hard dollar cap, often $10,000, on water losses from things like aging plumbing. Florida courts enforced those as well, and I'd be happy to offer you any of the cites from these cases if that's helpful to you. Now, let's see what happened, because this is the pattern that repeats. So mold was a claims category that went down and went down significantly. The exclusions worked for mold, but the contractors and adjusters who had built the business on assigned inflated claims did not retire. They did not move. They went looking for the next coverage that still paid, and they found it underground. So the system then migrates. Florida, as you know, similar to some areas in Louisiana, sits on limestone. Limestone dissolves. And so Florida homeowner policies have long had to deal with sinkholes, and that made sinkhole coverage the next frontier for claims inflation. Everyone knows what a sinkhole is. It's when a house basically falls or a structure falls into the ground. But their move was ingenious, and I mean that really as a criticism. A house in Central Florida, which is where a lot of this limestone is, develops cracks. They develop cracks in the drywall. They develop cracks in the foundation slab and in the driveway. These, in large part, are mostly cosmetic. They're not foundational. They're settlement cracks, the kind of thing that you see a lot in older homes or even homes that were just built just a few years ago. But now a public adjuster or a contractor would take an assignment of benefits. They would hire an engineering firm. They would reframe those cosmetic cracks as evidence of sinkhole activity. And because the cost to truly stabilize a home over a sinkhole— grouting, underpinning— can exceed the value of the house, a few cracks in a driveway could be leveraged into effectively a total loss sinkhole claim. These claims exploded, and they concentrated in a handful of counties, what we call the solo counties: Seminole, Osceola, and counties in the central part of the state of Florida. The Florida legislature responded in 2011 with Senate Bill 408, which was a comprehensive sinkhole overhaul. Before 2011, sinkhole coverage was effectively bundled in the homeowner's policy, so it was One cohesive policy. The reform split it in two. Under the current statute, Senate Bill 408 that was passed in 2011, every property insurer must provide coverage for catastrophic ground cover collapse. So if a house falls into the ground, that is covered. But it only need make available for an additional premium the broader sinkhole loss coverage. In other words. The legislature let insurers limit the mandatory baked-in coverage to true catastrophic collapse and sell the lesser sinkhole coverage damage as a priced option. The definitions here are key, and they are demanding. Catastrophic ground collapse cover requires all 4 of the following: an abrupt collapse of the ground cover, a depression visible to the naked eye, structural damage to the covered building, including the foundation, and the structure being condemned and ordered vacated by the government. And the statute also expressly says that mere settling or cracking of a foundation or structure does not qualify. That single sentence— settling and cracking do not count— was aimed directly at the cosmetic crack claim. Sinkhole losses The broader optional coverage is defined as structural damage caused by sinkhole activity, and the statute then defines structural damage through a detailed 5-part engineering test tied to the specific American Concrete Institute standards and the Florida Building Code, which is one of the strongest in the nation. The legislature was deliberately substituting engineering thresholds for adjectives, and the legislature required a very blunt disclosure. If a policy excludes sinkhole loss coverage, the insurer must tell the policyholder in bold type that the policy covers— that the policy covers catastrophic ground cover collapse resulting in the home being condemned and uninhabitable, but otherwise does not cover sinkhole loss unless the homeowner buys an additional coverage. In 2011, the reform that was put in place also required that paid sinkhole claims be recorded in the county's public records through the clerk of court. Specifically, an insurer that pays a sinkhole claim must file an engineering report, certification, legal description, owner's name, and the payment amount with the county clerk of court, who will then record it. Critically, as a precondition to accepting payment for a sinkhole loss, the policyholder must file any sinkhole report prepared on the property. A seller who received a paid sinkhole claim must also disclose it to a buyer before closing. So think about the incentive that recording requirement ultimately created. A paid sinkhole claim now attached a permanent publicly recorded cloud to the property's title, one the owner had to disclose when selling. Suddenly, the homeowner really had something to lose. And that's a big issue here, because what happens is folks feel like they don't have anything to lose by filing this type of claim. The reform married tighter coverage definition to a recording and disclosure regime that made frivolous sinkhole claims personally costly to the claimant. And it worked, again, for sinkholes. And for the coverage was restructured and the recording and disclosure requirement took hold. Lo and behold, sinkhole claims went away in the state of Florida. In case there's any question about the power of the legislature, just by words they changed the geography of the state of Florida. I say that in jest, obviously, but sinkhole claims did go away after the law changed. The vast majority of claims paid for sinkholes prior to the reforms were clearly frivolous based on what we saw After the reforms. But here's the important part of the whole story. We now had suppressed 2 man-made symptoms in the state of Florida: mold, which was gold, and sinkholes, which were really cracks in tiles or cracks in walls. But still, the patient was not well. Premiums in the state of Florida kept climbing. Insurers kept failing because we never touched the disease. So what was the disease? It was two things working together. Let me be fair to the original thought that I gave you because it started as consumer protection. Florida law has recognized for over a century that a policyholder can assign an insurance claim after a loss without the insurer's consent, similar to what you see in healthcare, similar to what you see in other Uh, lines of business. Florida appellate courts have called in an unbroken string of cases going back to 1917, uh, when there was a Supreme Court decision on that, uh, assignment of benefits. The rationale was humane. When your house floods at midnight, you can't wait weeks for the carrier to adjust the claim before the water damage spreads. Letting you assign your benefits to a contractor means work starts now. And the contractor, not the homeowner, can deal with the insurance company. As one court put it, repairing a home after a loss is time-sensitive, and insurance benefits are often the most ready means of paying for emergency repairs. Convenience for policyholders— that was the theory. In practice, it became one of the most powerful fraud vectors in the state of Florida, even today. Once the contractor holds the assignment, the contractor completely controls the claim. It sets the invoice, and this is the crucial part, it can sue the insurer's homeowner— or the insurer in the homeowner's shoes, and therefore the homeowner is ultimately out of the picture. The regulator could not fix this by form because when insurers tried to file endorsements restricting post-loss assignment, The regulator disapproved them, and the courts affirmed that a restriction on the right to assign post-loss benefits was contrary to Florida law, and the regulator found was not in the best interests of policyholders. The second half of the disease in the state of Florida is the economic fuel. Florida's one-way attorney fee statute that, again, was unique to Florida and in a lot of ways was a silver bullet. For the reforms that we put in place in 2022 and 2023. For decades, Florida Statute 627428 provided that when a policyholder or an assignee, so someone who got an assignment of benefits standing in the shoes of a policyholder, prevailed against any insurer, the insurer paid the claimant's attorney's fees one way. That's different than a typical type of tort action. where the attorney's fees come out of the payment. The insurer could never recover its fees from the claimant, no matter how inflated a claim was. Put the two together, assignment of benefits and the one-way attorney fee statute, and you had a machine that was unstoppable. The contractor takes the assignment, submits an inflated invoice, and sues over any shortfall. If the contractor recovers even a dollar more than the insurer offered, The insurer pays the contractor's lawyer. The economics are brutally simple. It's almost always cheaper for the insurer to pay the inflated claim than to litigate and win, because winning still costs money and losing costs the other side's fees— attorneys— the attorney's fees. Multiply that across hundreds of thousands of claims, and I'm not talking about hurricane claims. I'm talking about run-of-the-mill water and other claims. And you understand why Florida, a single state, came to generate a widely disproportionate amount of the entire nation's homeowners insurance litigation relative to its share of claims. From 2016 to 2024— and you might say, well, the reforms went into effect in December of 2022 and March of 2023. They did, but it takes time for the policies to renew and them to roll over. Right. So from 2016 to 2024, Florida accounted for between 64% and 80% of all homeowners insurance lawsuits filed nationwide, while accounting for somewhere between 7% and 16% of homeowners insurance claims opened over that same period. That is a staggering disparity and is exactly why we were in the bind we were in. Florida's first real attempt to deal with the disease came in 2019, and it's instructive precisely because it was too narrow. In 2019, AOB reform, which was House Bill 7065, did not abolish the assignment of benefits. It regulated them. The new statute required an assignment be in writing, give the homeowner a short rescission window, be delivered to the insurer within 3 business days, contain an itemized estimate, and carry an 18-point boldface warning that the homeowner was giving up rights and may be exposed to litigation against the insurer. It capped emergency service assignments at the greater of $3,000 or 1% of the dwelling limit. It imposed a pre-suit notice requirement on assignees. And a companion section let insurers finally sell policies that restricted or barred assignment so long as they offered an unrestricted version and priced the restricted one lower. The 2019 law also began to touch on the fee engine. It provided that in an AOB suit, the assignee could recover fees only under the general sanctions statute, Section 57. 105 in Florida rather than automatically under the one-way attorney's fee statute. This was some progress, but notice what 2019 did not do. It left the one-way attorney fee statute, Section 627428, standing for everyone except assignees. The disease had a workaround. If assignments were now regulated, the plaintiff's bar could simply create— litigate first-party claims directly. with the one-way attorney fee statute still paying their way. The machine kept running, which brings us to the reckoning. The disease continued to inflict massive losses on insurers from October of 2018 until February of 2023. 11 Florida-domiciled insurers went insolvent, including 6 companies during 2022 alone. As I mentioned earlier, I started doing work in the insurance space shortly after what then was the worst natural disaster, Hurricane Andrew, in August of 1992. To put this in perspective, 13 companies went out of business after that devastating storm. 11 companies went out of business in a lot of ways off of man-made issues in the state of Florida. During that period. Insurers were losing billions of dollars from an underwriting perspective year over year in the state of Florida. The massive reduction in capacity in the market with absolutely no private market replacement, because capital will go where capital feels welcome and it didn't feel welcome in the state of Florida, led to a massive surge in Citizens Property Insurance Company, Florida's state-run insurer of last resort. Citizens ultimately grew to a policy count of almost 1.4 million policies net. I say net and not gross because even during this time there were some insurers that were taking policies out of Citizens. So I think Citizens easily could have been 1.6, 1.7 million policies in the state of Florida with the potential for it to go to 2 million policies. That is an untenable and unsustainable position in a state where when you're using a state-run insurer, it's a pay-me-later structure because the rates are not effectively where they should be, and there's other issues of exposure and otherwise. Based on this, the legislature had to act definitively. Between 2021 and 2023, 2 regular sessions and a special session were called to deal with property insurance. Florida finally addressed the disease at its root. And let me give you the 4 moves that matter. Move 1, pre-suit notice. In 2021, Florida passed Senate Bill 76, making a pre-suit notice of intent to litigate a condition precedent to any suit under a residential or commercial property policy. The claimant must give the Department of Financial Services notice at least 10 business days before filing, and a court must dismiss a suit filed without notice. It took effect July 1st, 2021, and was then reinforced in the 2022 special sessions. This was a speed bump, a chance to settle before litigation, but by itself, was a symptom-level fix. Move 2, ending AOB for new policies. In the December 2022 special session, through the passage of Senate Bill 2A, the legislature did what House Bill 7065 had not. It outright prohibited a policyholder from assigning in whole or in part any post-loss benefit under a residential or commercial property policy issued on or after January 1st, 2023, an attempt to do so is void, valid, and unenforceable. So that is, for every new Florida policy, the assignment of benefit business model, the host organization for the last 15 years of abuse was simply gone. Move 3, repealing the one-way attorney fee statute. This is really the decisive one. In addition to prohibiting AOB in property insurance claims, Senate Bill 2A eliminated one-way attorney's fees in suits under residential or commercial property insurance policies. Then in March of 2023, House Bill 837 repealed Section 627428 outright. That was the one-way attorney fee statute, effective March 24th, 2023. The one-way statute that had made it cheaper to pay than fight, that had fueled the entire AOB machine and the direct first-party litigation that followed it, was eliminated completely. Property insurance fee recovery now runs through the ordinary two-way sanctions framework of Section 57105, under which a court awards fees against a party that pursues a claim or defense unsupported by the facts of law. Fee shifting became a sword that cuts both ways instead of a one-way subsidy for inflated claims. I will tell you that right before this law went into effect, the courts were flooded with 400,000 lawsuits for property insurance so that the one-way attorney's fees could be salvaged by attorneys. Move 4, the broader reforms of 2023. House Bill 837 was not an insurance bill. It was a tort reform bill, and the committee should understand the companion changes in that bill. Number one, and this was important, it shortened the statute of limitations for general negligence from 4 years to 2. It converted Florida from a pure comparative negligence state to a modified negligence system. A plaintiff found more than 50% at fault for his own harm recovers nothing. Medical malpractice cases were excepted from that. It reformed the insurance bad faith law, creating a 90-day safe harbor for insurers who tender the lesser of policy limits or the amount demanded, codifying that mere negligence is not bad faith, and imposing also a good faith duty on claimants. For satisfied medical treatment, evidence is limited to evidence of an amount actually paid regardless of the source of payment. The gross bill figured is no longer recoverable. And a claimant treated under a letter of protection must disclose a copy of that letter of protection, itemized and coded bills, any factoring company sale, the claimant's coverage status, and whether the claim was referred for the LOP treatment. Critically, if the claim— if the referral came from the plaintiff's attorney, this is disclosable and admissible notwithstanding privilege, and the law firm-provider financial relationship is relevant to treating the provider's bias. Taken together, the changes that were made in 2022 and 2023 did what a decade of mold and sinkhole fixes never could do. They removed the assignment of benefit mechanism and the fee subsidy that made claim inflation very profitable. They treated the disease. So did it work? A reform is only as good as its results, so let me give you the results. Let's start with the litigation itself. Florida's share of the nation's homeowners insurance lawsuits fell to roughly 41% Or half of what it was at the height on less than 5% of the nation's claims. This is obviously still disproportionate, but it's a dramatic break from the 64 to 80% that we saw in the prior decade. In July of 2026, Florida insurers reported their net loss ratios had improved by double digits since 2023, which they attributed to favorable claims and litigation trends. Following the Florida legislative reforms. Reuters reporting on the sector has repeatedly described the 2022 reforms as producing a significant drop in litigation claim frequency. Capital and carriers came back. The drop in litigation drew new entrants to the Florida property and casualty insurance market. Since April of 2023, so just a month after the last reforms were put in place, 27 new property insurance carriers have entered the Florida insurance marketplace. The capital markets are not a straight line, but the direction— private carriers returning to a market national insurers had been leaving— is real. Insurers returned to profitability in the state of Florida for the first time in a decade. According to S&P Global, Florida insurers collectively turned a profit in 2023 after 6 years of staggering losses, helped certainly by fewer storms. But the new law limiting litigation made a huge difference. The state insurers shrank. Citizens, Florida insurer of last resort, have ballooned to more than 1.4 million policies in September of 2023. An all-time high, up from about 1.1 million policies at the end of 2022 and approximately 400,000 policies in 2018. So think about this: in just a five-year period, it went up threefold because of the problems in the market. Through its depopulation effort, private insurers have taken hundreds of thousands of policies. Off of the state's back, more than 585,000 alone in 2025, and citizens' current policy count sits just above 250,000 policies. That is the clearest sign of a private market re-engaging in the state of Florida, and the rates began began to stabilize by late 2025. Florida's governor and insurance commissioner were pointing to rate filings as early stabilization, stabilization indicators. In January of 2026, Governor DeSantis announced rate reductions for Citizens policyholders averaging 8.7% statewide, with average Citizens reductions of 14% in Broward County, the second largest county in the state of Florida, 14% in Miami-Dade County, the largest county in the state of Florida, And almost 12% in Palm Beach County, and a staggering 11% in Monroe County, which is the Florida Keys. These 4 counties represent some of the most extreme coastal risks in the state of Florida, and the double-digit rate reductions in those counties are undeniable evidence that the reforms are working for Florida consumers. The benefits to consumers have been broader than homeowners insurance. There have been double-digit reductions in renters insurance rates, and not only rate reductions in personal insurance rates, but over $1 billion in rebates paid directly to personal automobile insurance policyholders in just the last 12 months in the state of Florida. Rate filings at the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation show that the fruits of tort reform are continuing to flow to consumers. The 30-day average rate request for homeowners insurance in October of 2026 was -2.3%, an improvement from -0.6% one year prior. The longer-term trend was also favorable. The 180-day average rate request was -1.7%, an improvement from effectively a wash one year earlier. The data does not lie. So let me close with the lessons I think that the Florida experience offers to Louisiana and frankly other states. There are 5. First, you need to treat the disease, not the symptom. Florida spent more than a decade on targeted fix mold exclusions. The 2011 sinkhole reform and the 2019 AOB reform. Each one worked on its own terms. None of them healed the market because none of them removed what made claim inflation profitable. The abuse moved simply to the next line of coverage. The Office of Insurance often called this whack-a-mole. Second, follow the money. In Florida, the engine was assignment of benefits compared to the one-way attorney fee stat— combined with the one-way attorney fee statute. Florida's engine may— Louisiana's engine may be something completely different. I cannot tell you what it is from where I stand, but there are professionals in the state who can, and that's where the work should start. Third, build a broad coalition. Florida's reforms held because the legislature, the regulator, insurers, the business community, the real estate community, and the defense bar worked towards the same goal. The legislature and the Department of Insurance are well positioned to lead that effort. In the state of Louisiana. Fourth, be bold. Florida passed 5 reform packages in 5 years, and the market didn't turn until 2022— until the 2022 and 2023 reforms went to the root of the problem. Targeted, careful reform is prudent, but reforms that only nibble around the edges leave room for significant abuse. Uh, fifth, hold the line. Florida's recovery is real, but it's not guaranteed. There are efforts in 2024 and 2025 to roll back those reforms. There will be efforts this year and in current and future years to do the same thing. Reform is not a single session. It's a commitment. And when the reform holds, capital returns because capital goes where capital feels welcome. Since 2023, as I mentioned earlier, 27 new insurers have entered the state of Florida writing homeowners and commercial property and casualty insurance. Citizens has gone from a high of 1.4 million policies with a significant, untenable, unsustainable liability on the back of citizens in the state of Florida to roughly 255,000 policies, which is a number we never thought we could reach. And Citizens policyholders in South Florida, where the risk is highest, are seeing double-digit rate reductions. The capital markets have shown they will reward a state that takes these steps. The reinsurance market has shown the same. And I'm confident the right mix of reforms can bring those results to Louisiana. And with that, Mr. Chairman, I will leave you with Go Tigers, and I'd be happy to answer any questions.
Kirk Talbot
Ditto that. What— and as far as auto insurance goes too, I was just Googling, you know, are rates decreasing in Florida? It looks like the top 5 auto insurers have requested or have dropped their policies 8%, their premiums. And I think the insurance commissioner said in 2026 alone, 80% of auto policyholders in Florida have seen a decrease. That's good. Congratulations. Tell us, is there, is there any one that got away? Is there any, any reform that y'all didn't get passed? That, I mean, is, is the reform continuing, or is it kind of like hitting the pause button now for 2027? And, or tell me where we are with that.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I, I think in a lot of ways it was a trust but verify situation. Folks on both sides of the aisle wanted to see if the reform stuck. We told everyone when we put the reforms in place, it was going to take 24 months to see any results. Lo and behold, 24 months later— and look, we sort of got lucky too, to be candid, with a lack of significant storms in that period, because significant storms could change a trajectory. Bottom line is, I think what we did until we see the next shoe to drop really has made a difference. And I think people want to just make sure that that continues to work. In the state of Florida. Could I see us looking at some things like even shortening some of the times for statutes of limitations? I'm not sure a statute of limitation for property insurance should be any longer than 1 year, yet it's 2 years still for some policy in the state of Florida. I would be remiss if I did not mention that the legislature, in reaction to some of the storms, Look, in today's environment, when I started doing this in 2020— in 1992, after Andrew, you could have a complaint ratio that was in the double digits for an insurer, and insurance departments would say that's explainable. Now, the ability to— of insurance departments to ramp down on the— if your consumer complaints are at like 1%, is extremely high. So what the legislature did in the state of Florida is to put more guardrails around the claims processes to make people more comfortable that insurers were doing their job. And so what I— I don't know that anything's going to be done in particular in the next couple of years. The issue you have in the state of Florida that you have in Louisiana, and we should be blunt about it, is there's an affordability crisis. And that affordability crisis transcends insurance. And when you think about rebuilding a home and insurance premiums and insurance rates, everyone's going to sit at a cocktail reception and tell their buddies and their friends that they're thrilled that their house that they bought 3 years ago for $500,000 is now a million-dollar home. Well, that means if there's a million-dollar loss, okay, should rates go up? Should premiums go up? I ask that as a rhetorical question, but I think the affordability issue Sometimes clouds this. Let— make no mistake about it, and I mentioned earlier, I teach insurance law at Florida State University where I've done that for 18 years. I start out my insurance law class by saying the following: insurance is a unique product in one particular way. It's the only product I know where you don't know the cost of goods sold when you price that product. Now think about that thought for a second, okay? Okay. If you go into any grocery store here and they sell you a case of beer, they know exactly what that case of beer costs. They know what their labor costs are. Insurance is the only product you don't know that. And by the way, the rate process is to get a rate filing through a department, even a good department, they're going to run you through the wringer to make sure that there's a comfort level. And so, So I think there are a lot of protections in place. Do I think the legislature in Florida will do anything going forward? I don't know. I think we showed that when you treat the disease, you do get some substantial results.
Kirk Talbot
And even as you said, even when you had a period of no storms, you had 11 companies fail.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Well, that was— and I appreciate that timeline there. But that was because— you're right, that was because of the— That wasn't because of Andrew-type hurricanes. Right. It was exactly— it was because of, of the man-made losses that we had. It was really because of the one-way attorney's fees, right, at AOB.
Kirk Talbot
Okay. Um, I do want to mention something real quick. I should have mentioned at the beginning of the meeting. We all know that, uh, State Representative Mike Bayham passed away last night. I just want to do a moment of silence for him. He was A great guy. I knew him for over 30 years going back to the mid-'90s, and he was a gentleman, and he was not afraid to stand up for what he believed in, and he had guts, and he was a great legislator, and I know we're all going to miss him very much. So just have a quick moment of silence for him. Thank you. Thank you. Representative Green, you're up first for a question.
Kyle Green
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you for being here, Mr. Karlinsky. My question to you is, I was listening to your testimony on the way here, and I have 2 questions. You mentioned about the tort reform efforts that were undertaken in Florida, and you mentioned That medical payments, right, that they had to guarantee LOPs with the care that a patient or claimant would've received. What's the correlation between that and homeowners insurance efforts taken in Florida?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
So, I appreciate that question. My point there was the 2023 bill was a tort reform bill. It wasn't just a homeowners insurance bill. So there really is no correlation between those two.
Kyle Green
Okay. Thank you for clearing that up. My next line of questioning, you mentioned about overinflated claims, correct, with respect to mold and other perils? Sinkholes, right? Okay. Are you— can you touch on whether there have been any allegations of underinflated adjustments in Florida? Specifically, if a claimant has made a claim for property damage, and reported that to their insurance company, and insurance company then comes to adjust it. There's been allegations specifically in Florida of those claims being slashed by almost 98%. Can— has that ever occurred?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Absolutely. So you have instances, a number of different instances. Number one, you have an instance where someone might file a claim for something that's not even covered or under a deductible. That would be a claim that's slashed. You also have unscrupulous adjusters out there and others. I mean, adjusters get paid on the amount of the claim. So we have seen a number of instances where those were overinflated on the beginning. And of course, you have an instance where an insurer may not get it right. So yes, there are instances of that.
Kyle Green
Are you familiar with the Heritage Property and Casualty Insurance? I am.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
They're a client of mine.
Kyle Green
Okay. Well, I have here that there's a random sample of 10,000 claims. And out of that random sample of 10,000 claims, 4,162 were revised downward, 2,583 were revised upward, and 3,300 remained unchanged. And the company blamed software tracking limitations and basically denied any intentional fraud. Can you speak to that?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah, I think that's I mean, I think you had a third that were on the money. You had 20% that were lower and 40%— or higher and 40% that were lower. I think when you're adjusting claims, it's not an exact science.
Kyle Green
So I think in Louisiana, we understand that there are bad actors on both sides, and we want to make sure there's a proper balance, because at the end of the day, you have the insured who's basically suffered a peril, and they just want to get back in their home as quickly as possible. Can you agree with that?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Absolutely.
Kyle Green
Has there been any measures taken by the Florida legislature to probably address some of these things that were outlined in the 60 Minutes report that was published, I believe, the fall of 2024?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah, which is the subject of a couple different lawsuits. But the legislature did, as I mentioned earlier to the chairman, put in place certain guardrails on claims reviews as well as timeframes to adjust Can you speak specifically as to what some of those adjustments are? I don't have those in front of me. I apologize.
Kyle Green
Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
It was— Norm, I'm great with numbers. I can't remember the legislation, but I'll get you a copy of the legislation that was put in place.
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
Thank you, Representative Green. Representative Jordan.
Edmond Jordan
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just on— I'll follow up on some of the line of questioning that Rep. Green had. And I just want to make sure I'm clear because I think I think in a way you were using inflated claims and frivolous claims almost interchangeable. Is that your intent?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I think they could be interchangeable, but I think they also could be separate.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I mean, I guess my question is this, because a frivolous claim is a claim— we'd agree it is a claim that's without merit, right?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Correct.
Edmond Jordan
All right. An inflated claim might be a meritorious claim, but you just Correct.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
All right.
Edmond Jordan
So, I mean, so I guess my issue with that is, and I know we always talk about litigation as being a, in this phrase, sort of a pejorative type term, but if somebody feels like they've been treated unfairly, you'd agree that the court system is a fair venue for them to go and try to redress some of their claims?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
No issue with going to court. The issue was with the one-way attorney's fees in Florida.
Edmond Jordan
Well, all right, so I'm glad you said that because that leads me to my next question. I know insurance industry, the insurance industry for a long time has been against a loser pays system. So would you be okay with, with a system that says that loser pays, somewhat like what we have in federal court?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Um, I'd want to look at that and study it.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I think it's very simple, and it's not a study. If you lose If I win my case, I get my fees, I get my attorney fees. If you win, you get your fees and everything else. I mean, it's a very simple process.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Having done this for 33 years, I can tell you I don't think anything's that simple.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I mean, it works very well in the federal court. The judge assigns somebody who's won, and he, in his order, says you're responsible for cost and attorney's fees.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Maybe we should send all these claims to federal court. I think that'd be a great solution.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I mean, again, we're talking about a part of a federal court system that works. That's very simple. But we don't necessarily need to change the venue of it. We're talking about using the same thing in state court.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I think the venue matters a lot.
Edmond Jordan
So, well, okay. You think the venue matters. So you're saying that the venue matters because of what? Is it because of the judge? Is it because of the jury? Because we just lowered jury trial thresholds. So, and this is the same thing I've mentioned to Commissioner Temple in the past, we lowered the jury trial threshold and then we say we don't trust juries. So I don't know how we have it both ways. So are you insinuating that some venues are more favorable than others?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'm not insinuating anything. I'm just suggesting to you that none of this is, is a simple equation.
Edmond Jordan
Well, you said venue matters, so I guess tell me what you mean. Okay, tell me what you mean.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I think federal— the federal court system is a, um, a different system than the state court system.
Edmond Jordan
I would agree on that. In, in what ways though? I mean, in particular, you— are you mentioning—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I mean, you have judges that are appointed for life. You have, um, it's, it's a It's just a more sanitized process, if you will.
Edmond Jordan
Certainly a quicker process. Okay. But no answer on loser pays. You just have to— I guess your point is you'd have to study that.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Right.
Edmond Jordan
All right. You know, I heard you say treat the disease. I think other people would say treating disease, we could also say rigging a game. So, I mean, It depends on what perspective you want to look at it from. Like you were talking about the assignment of benefits, you were talking about the mold claims, you were talking about the sinkhole claims. But specifically as to the sinkhole claims, at some point it was covered under the general policy. Insurance companies decided to remove that from the general policy and then charge extra for that on a separate policy.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
No, that's not accurate.
Edmond Jordan
Well, okay. So explain to me how did that work?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Ground collapse, which is when a house falls into the ground, is covered under the general policy. What was happening is where people were filing claims for cracks in tiles, cracks in walls, cracks in driveways.
Edmond Jordan
And at some point that was covered under the general policy.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
That was covered under the general policy, correct.
Edmond Jordan
And then that was removed. From the general policy and put in a separate policy. Correct. And you charged an extra premium for that.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Or you didn't have to get that.
Edmond Jordan
But that's just what I just said. So I'm not sure what was incorrect about that, but that's okay. So let's also talk about the modified— and I'll leave after this, because if we're talking about fairness in the system and we've passed this modified comparative fault, but Tell me what's fair about if you find me 51% at fault, I get nothing. But if I find you 51% at fault, I don't get 100%.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I don't— that's a question that I'm just not equipped to answer right now.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I mean, you mentioned it as a, as a positive sign of what the Florida legislature did.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I mentioned it as a change that was put in place.
Edmond Jordan
Right. I think you mentioned it in a positive manner.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I mentioned it specifically just as a change that was put in place.
Edmond Jordan
Well, you think it was a positive matter?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Do I think so? Yes.
Edmond Jordan
Okay. So again, so tell me where the fairness is in that, that whereas if you find me 51% at fault, I get nothing, but if I find you 51% at fault, I only get the 51% versus 100%.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'd have to look at all the case law and and see what, what, what's made sense over the course of time. I don't know.
Edmond Jordan
Well, I'm just saying from a pure mathematical standpoint, does that seem fair to you?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'm not gonna— I'm not gonna tell you what seems fair to me or not.
Edmond Jordan
All right, no further questions. Does it seem fair to you? Not at all. Not at all. I'm very clear on that. It is not fair. All right, we know.
Kirk Talbot
I think what's not fair What's not fair is someone can hit you and sue you. That's what's not fair. Senator Bass.
Adam Bass
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A couple questions. Earth movement is what you're talking about, and oftentimes FEMA is the one that covers that as it pertains to an earthquake. How did that play into the sinkhole discussion?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
You know, we don't talk a lot about earthquakes in Florida.
Adam Bass
We happen to be on a fairly large fault line in North Louisiana. I don't—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
it didn't really play into the discussion, to be candid with you. I don't recall ever talking about how earthquakes affected—
Adam Bass
But there's a clear definition in the statute that separates what an earthquake could do and what the language is for the sinkhole.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'd need to go back and look at that.
Adam Bass
Because I would be very interested in if were to have that, because Louisiana is on a fault line, how that would play out.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah, it's an interesting point. A lot of what we were looking at was just based on geography and limestone versus earthquake risk.
Adam Bass
I understand, but I, you know, we've actually had some earthquakes and it's been a topic of discussion, so I'm trying to understand. Is it safe to say that since you had, I think you said, a net gain of 1.4 million policies in your Citizens or insurer of last resort in Florida, that it wasn't necessarily a free market? Did you— you guys had a lot of companies that went insolvent, but did you guys also have a lot of companies that pulled out and refused to write business in your state?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
So it wasn't a net gain. It was just That was the number, the net number. It could have been higher if companies didn't take policies out. We did have some companies that withdrew from the state. We did have a number of companies, 11 companies, that went out of business.
Adam Bass
Well, as we went through this discussion, when we were trying to make some of these changes, we had an affordability problem, but we had an affordability problem because we also had an availability problem because we had so many insurers that chose to leave the state. Yeah. I think you made the statement that capital is going to go where capital is wanted.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Capital goes where capital feels welcome.
Adam Bass
Yes. And so when you're talking about capital, can you get a little bit into the reinsurance market with me as to how that affected everything with Florida's changes and the subsequent rate reductions?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Predictability. I mean, at the end of the day, as we talked about, insurance is the only product that you don't know the cost of goods sold when you price that product. The reinsurers are in a position where they can support something or not support it. And we're no longer in a world of risk transfer. We're in a world of risk finance, and it's worldwide, where you've got to go factor out your coverage to make sure that you've got enough coverage for a particular state or a particular risk. And so the reinsurers who are ultimately on the hook for a lot of these losses looked at what was going on in the state of Florida as unpredictable. And they would have significant losses and significant losses years after a treaty ended based on some of the litigation that they saw. So the reinsurer market dried up and costs were going up in that market, which ultimately go down to the policyholders. Reinsurers usually want data to make sure that things are working. They took somewhat of a leap of faith, came back, and rates tempered quickly. And that's where we found ourselves and where we find ourselves today. The reinsurance market also, I will tell you, there's a little bit more capacity there today than there was just a few years ago. So that's helped in and of itself. But The reinsurers and the insurers, in large part, in states like Florida and Louisiana, have things like hurricanes baked into their numbers and their losses. What they don't have baked in there is unpredictability.
Adam Bass
Well, my question there, I think you said y'all made some changes to your bad faith law?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yes.
Adam Bass
Did you guys have just one bad faith law, or did you guys have multiple bad faith laws?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
There are different bad faith laws and they've been interpreted differently based on different coverages.
Adam Bass
Were those used, different bad faith laws used to benefit however the case needed to be presented? Because we were experiencing some of that in Louisiana based on having multiple bad faith laws.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah.
Adam Bass
So my last question, since these changes, the major ones have have been enacted. Have you guys had a storm that has stress-tested this yet? As far— No. You haven't. So we're still waiting to see on the other end of this when we know we will have damage from storms. It's just a matter of time how it performs on the other end of this also, correct? Yeah. I think to both Representative Green's point, I think it's important to see how that functions on the other end to make sure those consumers have that protection too. But would you say today's insurance market in Florida would be classified, in your opinion, more of a free market state than it was previous to these changes?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I mean, I guess it depends. Is it more competitive? It's way more competitive. All right.
Adam Bass
Thank you, sir.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
You're welcome.
Kirk Talbot
Mr. Kolinsky, what Hurricane— is it Isaias? How do you pronounce that? Isaias. Isaias, which is a Category 2 that hit the Florida Panhandle. Um, have you— what have you learned from those claims going through with that hurricane with, with the new reforms you've done? Have you seen any significant chances how— or changes of how claims have been litigated, claims have been processed? Um, because I guess that's like the first storm that y'all have had since You've done some homeowners reform. Any lessons learned? Any unintended consequences? We should have tweaked this better, worse, or—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I don't think so. I think it worked exactly as people thought it would. Admittedly, so there were several storms the last couple years. They went into unpopulated areas, so they didn't have an impact. Right. Isaiah's was the first one that— Right, that hit a populated—
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
More of a populated area.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
30A and whatnot. It's a fairly concentrated area. It's less litigious than some other areas historically. And so, what was done there and what we've done in the state of Florida and what I think you've done, we've created these hurricane villages and other things. And so, really, what the insurers try to do now, probably more so than ever, is get out there very quickly and try to settle these claims so there aren't any Again, that was a much more concentrated area. I think to Senator Bass's point, you know, when something hits Miami or Tampa, will something be different? I think the answer, and I hope the answer is no, but that's a different ballgame than something hitting the Panhandle.
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
Okay. Senator Foil.
Franklin Foil
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Karlinsky, you had mentioned statute of limitations in your presentation. I guess dealing with property claims, we here increased the statute of limitations for tort matters from 1 year to 2 years under some testimony that it may lower insurance rates because you'd have less lawsuits. I'm not so sure that was a great policy. Do you have any comments if shorter or longer statute of limitations would help with insurance?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I would say, you know, my specialty is on the property side. And I would suggest to you that a longer statute of limitations on the property side leads to more opportunity for lawlessness.
Franklin Foil
I'm sorry, lawlessness?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah, lawlessness.
Franklin Foil
Right. So, you believe, based on your experience, then, that a shorter statute of limitation would be better for rates, or how—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I think it would be better for rates, yes.
Franklin Foil
Okay. And right now, We specifically had increased it for tort. We have not done anything with property in some time. But anyway, it was just something I thought I was thinking about when you mentioned that. So I appreciate your comments.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Yeah, I think for property, I mean, you know, I don't know how you wouldn't know you had damage to your car or a house within a year of some period.
Kirk Talbot
Yeah, and I don't know where you can have a supplemental claim, right? If you find something later, you file a sub. So there's a process for being able to do that.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Correct.
Franklin Foil
And I need to get the data. I'm not sure what it's done as far as our state has either cut down on lawsuits or not, but that was sort of the selling point, that you'd have less litigation. But we'll see. Anyway, thank you for your testimony.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Thank you. Thank you, Senator Foil.
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
Representative Glorioso.
Brian Glorioso
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I want to stick on the property side. I'll say we in Louisiana have a passed many of the reforms that you mentioned today. On the attorney's fee side, Louisiana has never been a state that allowed the insured to recover attorney's fees just because they got a dollar more.
Brian Glorioso
In Louisiana, they have to prove bad faith. And so they could— there could be a reasonable disagreement on what was owed, and the insured could be awarded that amount. But unless the insurance company had no rational basis not to pay, they didn't get attorney's fees. And so, that's always been a much more stringent standard in Louisiana. We've done a few things, I think, that were important, and I do want to commend the Commissioner on this. We had, I think, 11 or 12 companies go insolvent after Isaac or Zeta and the one that came right after that. And I think it was because they weren't properly funded. And the prior Insurance commissioner hadn't done the due diligence necessary to make sure that they were capitalized properly. And as a result, those companies didn't pay the claims, and Louisiana taxpayers are now paying those claims. And so I think the commissioner, Temple, has done a very good job of making sure that all of the insurance companies that are writing property here are properly capitalized and properly funded. And I think that is something that is crucial for us going forward because— We all know that we will eventually have another catastrophic loss in Louisiana, and we want to make sure that the taxpayers don't end up footing the bill because the insurance companies weren't capitalized and they were pulling the money out every year in bonuses or wherever else to their executives. And so I think we've done a very good job on that. I've worked as an attorney in the insurance area for 25 years. I can tell you what I've seen and what I'm very concerned about, which is Around Katrina, at that time, the difference between what the insurance adjusters would put down as the estimate and what a public adjuster would come up with was not huge amounts. It might be 30% or sometimes even 40%, but it wasn't 300%. And in the recent years, the last 10 years, I would say, as a general rule, The insurance company will come out and do an adjustment, and that adjustment might be 200% or 300% less than what the public adjuster does. And both of them are, in my opinion, bad faith adjustments. And I think the insurance companies have taken this— I don't know why they've taken this position, but they have been negligent in the way they've adjusted claims. And I think it maybe was to try to offset some of the inflated claims on the other side. But I think we need to find a way to get away from that. And we need to find a way to— that the insurance companies are fairly adjusting claims, and there's a reasonable process to work out the differences, in my opinion, pre-litigation, through some type of mediation or arbitration, to try to get these claims resolved as quickly as possible and fairly. Because at the end of the day, no one really wins in litigation. Even if the insured recovers down the road, they still didn't have the money to fix their house for 2 or 3 years. And so it's a lose-lose situation. Yeah. And so I have great concerns about the fact that when I first started practicing in this field, we had competent adjusters coming in from the insurance company early on who were trained, who did good adjustments. We had desk adjusters who had authority to resolve claims. Everything was done in person by the field adjusters. The desk adjusters really were just double-checking. They weren't really stepping in and rewriting estimates wholesale. And then the insurance companies all of a sudden made this change where the field adjusters have no authority. Many times they're completely incompetent and may have received a week's worth of training the day, you know, before they showed up and started adjusting these claims, the desk adjusters are trying to redo completely these adjustments with photographs. And to me, I think that their strategy seems pretty clear, is to delay and deny and hope that a percentage of the claims go away. How do we fix that problem? Because at the end of the day, what my concern is right now is we've gone so far on one side to try to give the insurance companies what they wanted to come back to Louisiana because we needed them to come back to Louisiana, that when we have a major issue, we're going to have a situation where our constituents don't get treated fairly and don't get their claims paid.
Kirk Talbot
You know, I'll jump in real quick, Representative Glorioso. So first, I want to point out, I believe it was Joe Bowie's bill, former Senator Joe Bowie passed a bill to increase The amount of equity or the amount of money that they— that companies had to have to be more financially solvent. But, you know, we did pass bills that increased the amount of time that they have to pay a claim, I think from 30 to 60 days for private and 60 to 90 days in commercial, where, you know, if you bump up on that 60 days or the 30 days in the old system, If you don't pay it in 30 days, you're in bad faith. And it forces, you know, when you have a storm and you have COVID and you have people that don't want to work and people that don't want to come here, there's no power, there's nothing to eat and no water. You know, it's hard to get a claim adjusted in that proper amount of time. So we've given them that extra time. We've also, in the bill I had that dealt with the whole claims process, you have, you know, if If you make a supplemental claim, a lot of jurisdictions were saying that's automatically bad faith, and we changed that. So I think you had, you know, part of the delay tactic was as soon as you write that first check, you're on notice for getting hit with bad faith. If anything, if they find something in the attic, mold or something that wasn't fixed, not all the time, but a lot of times, so, you know, that could be construed as bad faith, and we fixed that. So, Representative Glorioso, what I'm saying is I think And some of this was before you got here. We've done a lot to get to that point. God forbid, we know we're going to have another storm, and no one wants that, but it will be interesting to see how claims get handled under the new process. But go ahead and respond.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
Look, I think every time you go through one of these, you learn a little bit. I think these insurance villages have really made a difference. You talked about mediation and arbitration. I think those things are really helpful when you're trying to deal with claims. You know, I look back and think about someone selling a used car, and you have that 2000 Dodge that you washed every weekend, and you think it's worth something, and it's really not worth what you think it was. Yeah. And so, that's where you're going to find a disparity between between some of these things. Hopefully, there's a way to work out some of those disparities that's short of litigation. I think everyone can try to do better. But these insurance policies are guided by a contract. And if something's not covered, it shouldn't be covered. If something's covered, it should be.
Brian Glorioso
I think my concern, though, is that the adjusters, I think, is where we need to put our focus. Because at the end of the day, the attorney is based in their decisions on what the adjuster that they hired says, and the insurance company is making their decisions on what the adjuster they hired says. So we got away from this a long time ago in mortgages. And so if you want to buy a house, the bank has a list of approved appraisers, and they're randomly selected. Yeah. To me, I think we need to have competent adjusters who are licensed and required to take a certain amount of training. who are then on a random allotment in the state. And if a claim is made, they don't work for the insurance company, and they don't work for the insured. They're paid by the insurance company, but they don't have— you know, they can't be beholden to the insurance company. And the insurance company can't then override that because at a desk level, if we had people that were properly trained and properly licensed, And on a random allotment. And then we said, you're going to go out and you're going to do an adjustment that's fair. And if the insurance company doesn't like it, they still have to pay you. And if the insured doesn't like it, then they can appeal or whatever. But we're not going to have a person that's brought in by the insurance company that's completely beholden to the insurance company, that only gets paid and gets another job if they do what the insurance company wants, or the insurance company just overwrites it and the insured never No. Nobody ever sees what the actual first adjustment was because it gets changed by the insurance company's desk adjuster. And so we don't have good faith in that process. And then on the other side, you have the same thing. You know, the plaintiff's attorney goes out and hires their public adjuster, who, in my opinion, is incentivized to come up with an extremely high estimate to offset what they know is going to be an extremely low estimate. And to me, that's a broken system. And how do we fix that system so that we We have really fair adjustments done in a quick manner. We did do a lot of things on the timing here that I think is good to give opportunity for supplementals. But to me, until we fix that issue and we get really true fair estimates upfront, quickly and timely, we're always going to end up in a situation because the homeowner doesn't know. And so the homeowner gets an estimate and it's $10,000 and half of their roof is gone. They're like, well, I know this is not right. Right. And they don't know what to do. So they call a local attorney. The attorney calls a public adjuster. Public adjuster comes in and their goal is to get as much money as possible. So they come up and they have a $200,000 estimate. Both of those are probably wrong, right? How do we fix that?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
You know, I mean, that's the $64,000 question, I guess. It's the same thing we've been dealing with for years, same thing we nibble around I do think arbitration and mediation are good methodologies. I think they take some of the incentives out. You know, your comments, your thoughts about adjusters that are agnostic, if you will, is an interesting thought. But it's— I mean, if I could solve that, I probably wouldn't be before you guys today.
Kirk Talbot
And one thing I want to point out, I think it was Royce Duplessis's bill we passed last year or the year before. We're one of the I think one of only 2 states that has in statute that you have the right to hire a public adjuster. So insurance companies, which most of the time, if I recall, most insurance companies don't say in their policy, you know, you can't hire a public adjuster, but maybe one or two did in Louisiana. But I thought that was a good bill for the consumer to say, look, you have the right to hire a public adjuster, and that's in statute. One important question by Senator Bass: what is an insurance village, and how does he move there?
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'm not sure you want to move to an insurance village. That sounds like a fun place to live. But, um, I mean, I guess the village people live there. But, um, in any event, an insurance village is when, um, they come up with a specific location and they— each of the insurance companies has a tent or multiple tents there. They have check-writing abilities to write there. So this would be like a post-storm area?
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
Okay, I got you.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
They're bringing the adjusters and the adjustments Okay. Exactly there. You guys have done those before. Yeah. And, you know, basically what you do is you have everyone you can from the state level running around there trying to work deals with people effectively to say, look, we're in this quagmire. What do we think is right? And so in Florida, when that would happen, I remember getting calls from multiple state chief financial officers saying, Hey, talk to this company, make sure they're here, make sure they've got the right people, and let's have them move quickly. And so it's a— I got you. It's a more concise way to move something forward after a storm.
Kirk Talbot
All right. Representative Phelps, been waiting patiently. You're next. Thank you, Mr.
Tammy Phelps
Chairman. Going back to the question, Mr. Chairman, I don't know if this is for you or Commissioner. How have we addressed over the The last couple of years where we— going back to Representative Glorioso's point, a homeowner has several adjusters, 3 have been out, and ultimately resolved, it ended up in their claim being dismissed or not addressed at all. Have we—
Kirk Talbot
Well, we did. We did. It was my bill. We did a bill that the 3-adjuster rule, where, if that's part of your question, where we had in these— the post-Delta, Laura, Zeta, Ida, where people were getting 5 or 6 different adjusters, and every time they contacted their insurance company, they had to Explain the whole thing over again. So we said, look, when you hit the 3rd adjuster, that's it. They have to— no more. They have to give you a synopsis in layman's terms in your claim and of where you— the status of your claim and all that. So, and look, that's not— to my appreciation, it's not unusual to have more than one adjuster. You might have an adjuster come out first, and then you might have a unique damage problem where a different adjuster can better give you a more accurate adjuster. So that's not unusual, but we did stop that at 3. And that was a huge problem. I mean, I couldn't tell you how many calls I get where, you know, this is my 6th adjuster and I got to start all over again. I got to give them all the photos again. It's like they don't even know who I am or what they're doing. So it was a difficult situation.
Tammy Phelps
Thank you for mentioning it. I wasn't sure how we addressed that, but again, that's in my mind how the insurance companies were getting around servicing the customers. So I don't know, again, second question, if it's you, Commissioner, just for clarification. So we're hearing from Florida today. Are we— is this the only state we're hearing from?
Kirk Talbot
Yes, this gentleman happened to be in town, and we had some people in town for committee meetings, so I thought, you know, have him come by and just kind of tell us what's going on in Florida, because Florida Florida seems to be at ground zero, especially for homeowners, with their propensity for storms to make landfall. They're kind of like we are, so I just thought it would be interesting to see what they're doing over there in Florida.
Tammy Phelps (Louisiana Legislature)
Okay.
Tammy Phelps
And I know we've adopted some of their legislation before, so will we be looking at other states as well as we move forward?
Kirk Talbot
Look, I'm willing to look at— as long as we can get policies Premiums down for policyholders, I'll look at any state.
Tammy Phelps (Louisiana Legislature)
Okay.
Tammy Phelps
And I'm concerned about that. Let me just say for the record, and I'm talking to my colleagues, I have a big problem comparing Louisiana to Florida just in this sense. That's a whole lot of things that I have concerns about that I know it takes more than just looking at legislation and let's make it fit to Louisiana. Though I appreciate your time, Donna. I don't agree with a lot of it, but I hear you. You mentioned a part of homeowners giving up their rights somewhere in 2019 or a new bill. Can you expand a little bit on that? I didn't really hear what those rights were relative to or for what was the problem.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I think the 2019 bill was a change in AOB, the assignment of benefits. And so I don't know that any rights were given up necessarily. Is there a direct quote or what?
Tammy Phelps
Yeah, that's what I got. It's been a while. Homeowners giving up their right, and I just didn't know what you referenced to.
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
I'm not sure. I don't remember.
Tammy Phelps
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Kirk Talbot
Thank you. The board is clear. Does anybody else have any comments, any questions? Commissioner Temple, do you want to Anything you want to add to the— yeah, why don't you come up for a second? And I guess since we have you here in front of the Joint Committee, I know there have been rate filing decrease announcements. We've had some announcements of companies coming, writing in Louisiana now. We've found more money for the Fortified Roof Program. Maybe just give us kind of a little quick synopsis on the state of the state right now.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman and members. Tim Temple, Commissioner of Insurance, great state of Louisiana. I guess I volunteered to come before the committee, so please don't abuse that. Yeah, but I did want to take the opportunity to provide you with an update. I think we sent a letter— last time we sent a letter out giving you an update was sometime in late August on the impact of some of the changes and changes in market conditions. To date, as of November, we now have 25 newly licensed homeowner companies in the state of Louisiana, 11 of those just in 2026. So, and I will attribute that to the fact that a lot of the reform that you, the legislature, took and acted on is a driving force behind that. We are making Louisiana a more attractive place to do business. We are restoring confidence in the insurance marketplace, in the capital, insurance capital, to come and do business. In addition to those 25 companies, we have 4 more currently going through the regulatory process to go through the application, fund, and start to write business. So, I can't tell you of those total 26 how many are actively writing today because they don't report their information until at the end, after the end of the year, but certainly after December 31st, we'll be able to give you an update. And I'm sure we'll be talking about that during next session. With regards to rate changes, y'all have heard a lot about the reductions in private passenger auto. This year, in 2026, we've had 46 companies have taken a rate reduction averaging about 2.5%.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
That's on top of the 37 companies that took rate reduction last year, which averaged about 4.5%. And I want to say average because some of those were Plus 10% rate reductions, obviously some were less to get that average.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
But 2025, that equated to about $360 million less that we all were paying in our homeowner— I'm sorry, in our private passenger auto insurance.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
This year, it's around $70 million less, that 2.5%. So again, that's money that we are not paying to insurance companies.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
That's money that we are saving. And I say saving, it's being spent elsewhere in other— Right. expenses that we all have. So, on the homeowner side, we've— in 2025 was the first year in 5 years that we saw rate reductions. I think we have 16 companies that have taken rate reduction this year. The current average is around 0.5%. Last year, it was around 5% rate reduction. And again, those are averages. Some companies are taking more. Some companies are taking less. So there are savings out there for consumers. And look, I do town halls. I travel the state. I am constantly engaging with the public. And at every event, people are coming up and telling me, I am saving money on my insurance, whether it's homeowners, whether it's autos. Some people, it's both. And look, the other side of that, there are some people that come up and say, I didn't get a change. Some people say it didn't go down, and I'm very happy that it didn't go down. Some people say it went up. And then I have to engage in conversation. How old is your home? How old is your auto? Did your roof go from a 9-year to a 10-year? Is it now replacement costs? There's a lot of factors, and y'all know the complexities of that. But again, I appreciate Mr. Kolinsky coming and talking about the reforms that Florida did, because it does matter. And we do look— Representative Phelps, we look at all the states. We're not trying to cherry-pick any one. We want the best and brightest ideas from all the states and try and see what makes sense. And not every time a law changes in one state means that we need to apply it here. Obviously, Louisiana is somewhat unique. But we try and pick what makes sense so that we can, as the Chairman said, do everything within my power as a regulator and your power as legislators to help bring about more reform, more competition, and lower insurance premiums for everyone. And if I could, Representative Glorioso, I just want to touch a little bit on your concern too with the adjusters, because I think you make a very valid point.
Kirk Talbot (Louisiana Legislature)
He's got a question. Go ahead, Representative Glorioso.
Brian Glorioso
You can finish and I'll ask that. Okay.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
And I think you made a very valid point on the concern with adjusters. But if, you know, we need to set the context. After an event, after a catastrophic event, when you have hundreds of thousands of claims, and you have thousands, if not tens of thousands, of adjusters coming into a state. Louisiana, we license, we test and license the adjusters that are licensed under the state of Louisiana. So we have a little bit more regulatory oversight and raise the bar compared to some other states. I'm very proud of what we do in our state with regards to adjusters. But I can't prevent outside adjusters from coming in. What I can do, and what I've done in the 3 years that I've been Commissioner, is at the beginning of hurricane season, I have called in the top 20 property writers by premium volume. I've asked them to send their senior claims person. They come to the department, we sit down, we have a half-day meeting, and we set expectations. And I'll tell you, my expectation is if we get hit, or when we get hit with the next catastrophic event, hurricane, if I'm commissioner, they will embed a senior claims person at the Department of Insurance. So as claims are taking place, as adjusters are trying to get into jurisdictions, maybe they can't because of whatever reason— law enforcement, whatever the circumstances are— there is going to be a much closer touchpoint between myself as a regulator and the insurance company claims response. If we're hearing cases of maybe adjusters aren't showing up on time, maybe the person just doesn't like the way the adjuster came out and presented themselves, whatever it is, I'm going to be able to to pull the representative from that insurance company, the claims person, and say, what's going on? There's going to be a much more— there's going to be a lot more oversight on—
Kirk Talbot
Commissioner, we passed a bill, I believe in 2024, that made insurance companies submit to you a catastrophic plan saying— in other words, we said, look, we have a catastrophic event. How are you going to get adjusters down here? Where are you going to hire them? Where are they going to stay? How are they going to eat? Where they're going to sleep. And now they have to submit that. They have to submit that. Whereas before we just, you know, and unfortunately you can't just— we don't have 20,000 adjusters just sitting around Louisiana waiting for a storm to come. You know, you have adjusters here, right? But when a storm comes, they have to come in. And, you know, that was a bill we collaborated on to say, look, give us a plan. Show us how you're going to live, where you're going to live, where you're going to eat, how you're going to get them down here. So, uh, yeah, that was part of that. Good point, Mr. Chairman.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
But the point I'm trying to— I want to make is that there is going to be much more strict oversight in interaction between myself and the insurance company claims response. I'm happy to answer your question.
Brian Glorioso
Thank you, Commissioner. I'm going to touch on the adjuster thing real quick, and then I'm going to go back to the other question I had. So, and I appreciate your response there. What I'd like to see us look into, and I know we have a conference coming up that I'm going to attend, which is the national conference. of insurance legislators. If you look at how the energy sector handles storms, so Entergy and Cleco, they have cooperative agreements with all of the other power companies, and they stage, and they're ready to come in when the disaster is coming. I think we can do the same thing with adjusters. So, if we work with all of our Gulf Coast states to start with and say, let's come up with a uniform criteria for adjusters, uniform training, and let's have a cooperative agreement that says— Right. If we all pass legislation that says this is what the minimum requirements are, and when there's a catastrophic issue, there's reciprocity, and then they can stage and come in so that we— instead of having to get people a week's worth of training or hours' worth of training, we have a large pool of trained adjusters across the entire Gulf South, so they know hurricane claims, which is primarily our biggest risk, and then they can stage and come in just like we do in the energy And I think that what timing is, is of accidents, of course, when people are out of their houses. But I think a lot of times when you have an inexperienced adjuster come in and you have a really bad adjustment upfront, it really kind of sets the stage for bad outcomes down the line and makes it much more expensive. And I think part of the reason we extended some of the times is we recognize that it's better to wait 30 more days and have a very good adjustment than to get a terrible adjustment in 7 days and then have 5 more come after it. And I think the goal is to get people made whole as quickly as possible. And as quickly as possible may not be in 30 days. But I think it would be better to do a good job in 90 days than a bad job in 30 days. And I know we're all working towards that goal. So I think we just need to look at all options. What I wanted to ask about is— and I say this every time I speak to constituents, I've heard you say the same thing— the market is much different than it was 15 It's not like it was 15 or 20 years ago where people stayed with the same company for 20 years. And so we always tell everyone, you got to shop your coverage. You constantly have to be checking because you could get the same coverage on a homeowner's policy for $2,000 or $3,000 less with a different company right now. That used to not be the case. And so is there a way that we could adopt a uniform application for residential homeowner's policies that was used by all carriers so that it would be very easy for consumers to easy shop? Yeah. for homeowners to submit an application out to a broad spectrum of carriers at one time and then to get quotes back, so they're not spending a week trying to figure out every local agent and calling every local agent? I know that's done in the real estate industry. In Louisiana, we've adopted uniform contracts for residential real estate. Is that something that's ever been done anywhere else? Is it something we can look at? Do you even approve the application? for residential homeowners' policies?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
The forms have to go through the department. There's a regulatory process for that. But a lot of the, I would call, boilerplate language is done through the ISO, the Insurance Services Office, where each individual carrier, my understanding— and obviously, I think there's representatives in the room here for the industry— every state has some unique place, especially Every law, every, you know, states have different laws, 60 days, 90 days to adjust claims, a lot of different nuances like that, where they have to have their own. You can't just have one type of one policy that would, or one application form that would, I think, go throughout the state or throughout the country. So there are regional differences, regional nuances that would necessitate having to have state-specific—
Brian Glorioso
Real estate sector, because Louisiana's law is very different on property than others. We have a Louisiana-specific that's approved by LRAC. Could we have one uniform application for residential homeowners policies that all the carriers use so that a homeowner only had to fill out one 10-page application and they could submit it to 20 different carriers, as opposed to having to spend all this time for different applications? It would make it much more efficient for those homeowners to get more quotes and get better rates if there was a If there was one uniform application, and the residential doesn't change that much, you can always— the insurance companies could always ask for a supplemental. But if there was one uniform application that was approved by your office that they could submit to all 20 to get an initial quote, I think it would be beneficial.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
I would say we could have a conversation about that, and I don't want to try and poke holes in it, but I mean, if you got an application that says, do you have a pool? No, I don't. Do you have a dog? No, I don't. Because those are underwriting factors. If that were to change at some point in time and you don't update update your application? Are you now in violation of your policy form? I mean, again, I think that there's— I appreciate the concept. I don't know that that's done anywhere else. But I'm certainly willing to have conversations with the industry and see if that's even something that—
Brian Glorioso
Well, I mean, the industry is not really interested in people saving money. They want them to buy their policy.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
No, they— the industry wants to be able to rate accordingly and charge the correct premium for the risk they're assuming and not More, but we see significant differences in the same market right now.
Brian Glorioso
You would acknowledge that, right? I mean, like in my market, for the exact same policy with 4 different companies, the difference in price could be $3,000 or $4,000.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
I don't know who your agent is.
Brian Glorioso
No, I mean, I'm talking about multiple agents across the line. The premiums that are being charged are very different. And it used to be 20 years ago, the difference between State Farm and Allstate might have been a few hundred dollars. a year. It's very consistent now that you could have a couple of thousand dollar difference in the exact same coverage and policies between different carriers right now in South Louisiana. Is that something your office is even looking at? Or—
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
I would say that, again, because of increased availability to data, to information, that insurance companies are able to more accurately price.
Brian Glorioso
But, you know, I mean, these companies are in business to make money, so they're going to charge whatever most they can charge and get away with is, right?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
I think that insurance companies are in the business to pay claims. And at the end of the day, if they can make money, they do. And if it's— and if we see in years that they don't—
Brian Glorioso
Yeah, that hasn't been my experience with the insurance companies. But—
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
Well, as always, I would invite you to come to the Department of Insurance. Be happy to sit down and show you all of the data that we have access to.
Committee vice chair (Louisiana Legislature)
Thank you. I also would say you're then moving the job of the agent to the department, and one uniform application. Every agent may not be licensed with every single company in the state. So as long as agents continue and their advice continues to be sound, one application across every company— I know very few that are licensed with every company in the state, especially with us adding them. Senator Barrow has a question. Thank you, Mr.
Regina Barrow
Chairman.
Committee vice chair (Louisiana Legislature)
Okay. There you go. Are you on?
Regina Barrow
Thank you, Mr. Vice Chair. Thank you so much, Mr. Commissioner. So glad to see you this morning. And I first want to thank you and your team for always making yourself available, certainly showing up for community meetings. Ron Henderson has almost become a staple In my community, when we have hearings or community meetings, he's always there, or he sends a representative, but he's there most of the time to answer questions and to be engaged. Certainly after the series of hurricanes, the flood of 2016, we have had many, many questions as it relates to insurance. And I'm happy to see the changes. that have been made and the level of communication that has actually taken place to keep people engaged. Uh, your office has done a really good job of that, and I appreciate that. Not that we always agree, but certainly, uh, you are always there and your people are always there, and they're always answering the questions of my community.
Brian Glorioso
I, I just have a few questions.
Regina Barrow
Uh, so I do want to follow back up on the adjuster issue, and as you were talking, Representative Glorioso, I thought about the interstate compact kind of like initiative. Maybe that could be something that we could actually visit or take a look at with some of our neighboring states in terms of setting up some like cooperative endeavor and having those people on deck. Because after Hurricane Ida, we went through So much with the insurance company, and it was the insurance department that helped me with my parents. And I'm just wondering about all of the other, especially older individuals. And I know that you have an office set up for them, but my concern is always how people know. And if they don't have, you know, a legislator that they can call, how do they engage and make sure that there's somebody that is representing them? Because if I had not been there for my my parents, I can only imagine what would have happened with them with the adjuster because they really refused to actually have their roof repaired— not repaired, replaced. They kept wanting to repair it and it kept— every time they would repair it in one place, it would begin to leak in another place.
Brian Glorioso
So I can only imagine what that would look like for someone else who did not have a Regina Barrow, right?
Regina Barrow
And so I'm just thinking about things that we may be able to take a look at, and that may be something that we can visit about, you and I. But then I want to also follow up with you about the Blue Tarp program with the Fortified Roof. I was listening as I was walking in, and I heard you mention that. And I'd like to know, has there been conversations? Are we beginning to marry the 2 broker programs?
Regina Barrow
Because we know that if individuals have to replace their roof, It's better, especially if they qualify for the program, if they can do it with a fortified roof.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance) Sample Client (roofing contractor)
Yes, ma'am. And thank you, Senator. On your first part, September 11th, 2024 was when Hurricane Francine came ashore in Louisiana. That was so far my first and only hurricane as commissioner. I'll tell you one of the things that we did, and you heard Claims villages that were mentioned in Florida. Insurance companies have these mobile claims vehicles, and they drive them down, and they actually preposition. And Representative Glorioso, kind of like you were tying in with the utilities, when they know a storm's coming, you know, these vehicles aren't sitting in a garage in Baton Rouge or in New Orleans. They're in other parts of the country. They actually preposition. Right. And they let me know when they're coming down and they say, you know, Commissioner Temple, this vehicle will be in Shreveport on Monday night. And as soon as the storm clears and law enforcement allows people to get back in, it will be, you know, setting up at this location so that we can help communicate these— where they're going to be set up. And I think the Claims Villages is very similar. What we— and again, my intent, and I hope I don't have to use it, but my intent is to, again, work with the industry to make sure that we are trying to properly stage and position adjusters in areas. And if that's an area where, you know, you've got, you know, an elderly population and they maybe they don't have the ability to go out to a village, a claims site, we will help facilitate that. And I know that you and every legislator would be a line of communication there. With regards to the Fortified Roof Program, yes, this year the legislature, because of legislation y'all passed last year, Rededicating a portion of premium taxes and fees that the department already collects. And then we did increase the fees on the insurance industry itself slightly. We now have $30 million a year dedicated to fund the fortified roof. This year, we were also able to allocate— and the legislature passed a law that allowed $50 million— that was, I would say, $50 million that Louisiana citizens had that we were able to reallocate to the fortified roof program. So $80 million this year. By far the most that the program has ever had in the 3 years it's been in existence. The governor recently was able to identify and rededicate or reallocate another $20 million of federal money, and that's a separate program from the department's grant program. As you know, you can apply and receive up to $10,000 to fortify your roof. Mm-hmm. When you get that fortified roof, when you have that certificate, you get a reduction in premium. There are credits filed by every admitted insurance company. Starting January 1st, we have— we, the department, promulgated a rule, and we identified benchmarks that they have to hit. Insurance companies have to hit, and they're higher than what I would say the average is out there. Insurance companies can still deviate off that, but they have to come and demonstrate why. They have to present their case to the department and say, we can't make 22%, but we can do 20%. But they can't just ask for it and And think that they're going to be granted that. They have to make a financial case why they can't make it. They can also exceed the benchmarks as well, and there are many companies that exceed what we are doing. So the program, you get the reduction— I'm sorry, you get the fortified roof, you get the certificate, you get the reduction. And again, this is, as you know, designed to keep the shingles on your house and the water out of your— your shingles on the roof and the water out of your house. And if you do that, A $10,000 claim, you know, $10,000 worth of roof damage or exterior damage, when the water comes in, it becomes a $50,000 or $100,000. And that might be part of why you're seeing some of these claim numbers under the deductible increasing, because homes are being built stronger. They're incurring less damage than they had historically. So they're not these big claims that they used to be. But the Fortified Roof Program is by far— we are the fastest growing state. in the country for fortified roof. We have over 16,000 fortified roofs now since the first certificate was awarded, was granted on November 7th, 2023. That's 16% of all fortified roofs in the country. Okay. And that's growing every day. We are in the process, we're about to do round 10. That's going to be another 5,000 fortified roofs. And then when our fiscal year starts next year, we'll have another $30 million and we'll do another 3,000 So, we are the fastest-growing state in the country for fortified. Also, Chairman Talbot passed a bill last year that you can receive up to a $10,000 tax credit— Credit. If you choose to put your, you know, put a fortified roof on yourself and not go through the program. You can also get a tax deduction if you don't qualify for the tax credit. So, there's a lot of incentives out there— grant money, tax money, And then also the financial incentive that you lower your insurance premiums when you get the fortified roof.
Commissioner described $80 million in state Fortified Roof grants this year, a new rule setting minimum premium credits, and rapid program growth, which directly affects a roofer's demand and marketing.
Regina Barrow
And I'm so glad to hear all of that. I mean, I know about some of the things that we passed, and I'm glad to hear that, but I'd like to know, is it being integrated at all with the Blue Tar program?
Regina Barrow
Are people being made aware that as they are repairing their roof, that this can be an option? And I know that there's a cost upfront for them as well, but is it being integrated?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance) Sample Client (roofing contractor)
It's not— I don't think it's being integrated in the way that you may be thinking, and I want to further understand that. But you can buy an endorsement on your insurance policy so that— a fortified endorsement. And that would mean that if your roof was damaged and needs to be replaced, if you have this endorsement on your policy, the insurance company will put a fortified roof on— they will replace your damaged roof with a fortified roof. That's not directly addressing the Blue Tarp program. Okay. I think that, and I appreciate what you're saying there, and that might be a way that Louisiana could even leverage this program even further. I can tell you that as far as I know, Louisiana is the only state that also has local monies doing Fortified. Orleans Parish, Jefferson Parish are both, they've allocated local tax dollars toward the Fortified program, and we're actually working with them so that if a recipient in one of those parishes gets awarded a grant, but they don't have the gap, the difference between the $10,000 that they get through the grant program and say it's $14,000— and I think $14,000 is the average— if they don't have that $4,000, local governments are now coming in and saying, we want to keep that grant in this parish. We're going to spend some money and help you make sure you get that grant. We're also working with some of the NGOs, the non-governmental, the nonprofits, to help They've got pilot programs. We're working in conjunction with them to help identify people that when they get a grant, make sure that— again, sometimes it's people that don't have access to a computer or are not familiar enough with or confident enough to use the computer for an application process. We're working with those NGOs so that they can sit down with them, fill out the information, so that they have every opportunity to take advantage of that grant.
The fortified endorsement lets insurers replace damaged roofs with fortified ones, and local parishes are filling grant funding gaps, both of which could steer more roof work to certified contractors.
Regina Barrow
And that's very important because I think a lot of times we take some things for granted. We think people have access. We think people know. And when I say integrated, I mean, are they being at least made aware that this is an option so that they can get this? And if they invest a little money, then rather than just putting back on the standard roof, they can get the fortified roof. That's what I mean by integrated.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance) Sample Client (roofing contractor)
And I try in every Anytime I have any microphone in front of me, I always try and talk about the fortified roof program and making people as hyper-aware as possible. I can tell you that the roofing companies have done a good job of advertising for that. I hear on radios, you know, roofing companies will say, we do fortified roofs. I see it on sides of trucks. I've seen it on a few billboards, primarily going back towards Hammond on I-12. I've seen there's a couple of roofing companies there that advertise that. So I think everybody can play a role in promoting the fortified roof and letting people know that that's an option. Again, either through the grant program, do-it-yourself and get the financial incentives there, working with additional parish governments. I've recently spoken with St. Tammany Parish and I was in Lafayette Parish government telling them about the local ways that they can help. encourage and support the Fortified program. But I like the idea about the blue tarp. That would be an ideal time to let people know that that's available, and I think there might be some way we could do that. And I would like to see Louisiana do it because, again, that would be something no other state is doing, to my knowledge.
The commissioner endorsed promoting fortified roofs, including to blue tarp households, and praised roofing company advertising, signaling opportunities for contractors to be tied into outreach and post-storm roof replacement.
Regina Barrow
Absolutely. And so maybe we need to be having a conversation with the Louisiana Housing Corporation to make sure that maybe there's a box in the application so that way it's never missed. Regardless of who's taking the application, that they ask the question.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
And if I could also add, the federal government, because a lot of times they will come in and help fund. And so if they're going to allocate funds for rebuilding, let's make sure it gets rebuilt to the best standards.
Regina Barrow
At least making sure that we ask them, giving them an opportunity.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
Yes, ma'am.
Regina Barrow
Yeah. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Vice Chair.
Committee vice chair (Louisiana Legislature)
Thank you. And Mr. Kolinsky, I know you have to catch a flight. It looks like we have one One more question. Representative Jordan.
Edmond Jordan
Thank you, Mr. Vice Chair, and I'll be brief. Thank you, Commissioner, for coming in. Let me just start off, I guess, on a couple of things you talked about, the blue tarp, because I know when we talked about the fortified roof, one of the things we had proposed at one time that didn't get addressed was, you know, trying to have an income matrix where people of lower incomes might move up As far as being able to qualify for the program. I know we don't have that, but I think what Senator Barrow said as far as the blue tarp, if somehow we could give a preference to them, I think it somewhat accomplishes a similar goal. Because I would assume that somebody who has a blue tarp on their house, and if they had it for a while, it's simply because they can't afford to put a new roof on. And so if we could get to that, I think that would probably help us. Thank you. a lot. So I really like that idea. The other thing is the fortified endorsement. Has the department placed or dedicated any funds to advertising that to the public?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
No, sir. We have very limited funds as it is for any really messaging, and we have not promoted. But again, I think it's incumbent upon the insurance industry themselves to promote their products. I mean, certainly we want people to know that there are, you know, programs like that. But as far as the endorsement, that is not something that we— other than in conversations here and conversations with members like yourself that we have, there's been no marketing campaign.
Edmond Jordan
No, that's fine. I was just wondering about that. All right. On the company, That, that you said, the 24, 26 companies, whatever that number is that's coming in the state?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
25.
Edmond Jordan
25. How many of them are rated by AMBEST versus Demotech?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
I don't know that number, but I would, I would, to, I think the point you're trying to get to, I would hazard that most of those are Demotech-rated companies, if not all.
Edmond Jordan
All right. Um, I mean, that's fine. Like, I understand, I understand where we, where we, where we're going with that, and we We want new companies in. We want the competition. Just, I would like to know if we could have a solid number. If you're telling me all of them, fine. If not, then—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
If I may, Representative, AMBEST requires you to reinsure to a 1-in-250-year storm. Actually, I think it's 2 250-year storms.
Edmond Jordan
If you look at what the reinsurance costs on that, it would almost be cost prohibitive Well, I just know a few years ago there was some controversy related to companies that were being rated by Demotech and whether or not they were actually paying for those ratings. And so I'm not sure if that's been corrected, but that remains a concern as far as— for me anyway, because I hadn't heard anything to the contrary. So if that's been corrected— It's been corrected. I can just tell you what the—
Fred Karlinski (Greenberg Traurig)
why most companies would go to an alternative rating agency other than Best.
Edmond Jordan
No, I understand why. I just— because of the issues with them, I just want to know that. And then I guess the other thing, it kind of ties back into— I know we were given incentives. Have we seen companies, once the incentives expire, have they been withdrawing from the market, or how does that look?
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
Yes. And, Representative, I've I think, as you know, I was not in favor of those incentives. I didn't think that they were addressing the underlying problem. I see. We submit a report to the legislature every year updating on the status of that, and I, off the top of my head, I don't know. Again, I don't think it incentivized more than actually some of the fundamental changes that the legislature has addressed. I think changing the laws probably is more you get more incentive than just giving insurance companies money and asking them to come write more business. So, I'll get the most recent report that we submitted and make sure you get a copy of that so you— so we know where we are.
Edmond Jordan
I appreciate it. That's all I have. Thanks a lot.
Committee vice chair (Louisiana Legislature)
All right. I want to personally thank both the Commissioner and Mr.
Committee vice chair (Louisiana Legislature)
Kerlinski for coming in, providing testimony today. We really appreciate it. I think it's very important. It's important for us to stay on top of what's going on in the insurance market. And on a motion by Senator Wheat, we are adjourned.
Tim Temple (Louisiana Department of Insurance)
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you.